Gone Silent: Google Play Drops Nothing Chats Amid Privacy Concerns

By Fred Wilson, a tech enthusiast and a former app developer

Have you ever wished you could send iMessages to your iPhone friends from your Android phone? If you are a Nothing Phone 2 user, you might have been tempted to try out Nothing Chats, a new app that promised to bring iMessage support to Android. However, you might have also noticed that the app has disappeared from the Google Play Store just a day after its launch. What happened to Nothing Chats, and why did Google Play drop it amid privacy concerns?

Nothing Chats: A Brief Overview

Nothing Chats was a messaging app created by Nothing, a British tech company that produces smartphones and other gadgets. The app was powered by Sunbird, a US tech firm that specializes in Android and web messaging. Nothing Chats claimed to offer the following features to Nothing Phone 2 users:

• iMessage support: The app allowed users to send and receive iMessages to and from iPhone users, using their iCloud account credentials.
• RCS support: The app also supported Rich Communication Services (RCS), a protocol that enables enhanced features like high-resolution media, read receipts, and typing indicators on Android devices.
• End-to-end encryption: The app used end-to-end encryption to secure the messages between the sender and the receiver, without storing them on any server.

Nothing Chats was launched on November 17, 2023, as a beta version for Nothing Phone 2 users in North America, the EU, and other European countries. The app was supposed to be preloaded on the upcoming Nothing Phone 3, which is expected to be released in early 2024. Nothing CEO Carl Pei said that the app was designed to break the barriers between iOS and Android users, and to challenge Apple’s dominance in the US messaging market.

Nothing Chats: The Privacy Issues

However, soon after the app’s launch, several security experts and tech journalists raised serious concerns about the app’s privacy and security practices. Some of the issues that were reported include:

• iCloud account access: The app required users to enter their iCloud account credentials, or create a new one, to use iMessage on Android. This posed a risk of exposing the users’ personal data, such as photos, contacts, and emails, to Sunbird or other third parties.
• SMS interception: The app also required users to grant permission to access their SMS messages, which could allow the app to intercept and read their verification codes, passwords, and other sensitive information.
• Malware potential: The app used a workaround to mimic an iPhone device and communicate with Apple’s servers, which could violate Apple’s terms of service and trigger a response from Apple. Moreover, the app could potentially install malware or unwanted software on the users’ devices, or hijack their messages for malicious purposes.

Nothing Chats: The Play Store Removal

In response to the privacy issues, Google Play decided to remove Nothing Chats from its store on November 18, 2023, citing violations of its developer policy. Google Play’s privacy policy requires all apps on its store to disclose the types of data they collect, store, and share, regardless of the target audience. The policy also prohibits apps that are deceptive, malicious, or intended to abuse or misuse any network, device, or personal data.

Nothing announced on its official Twitter account that it was pulling the Nothing Chats beta from the Play Store as it worked out the bugs. The company also apologized to its users and assured them that it was committed to providing a safe and trusted experience for everyone. Nothing did not specify when or if the app would be available again on the Play Store.

Nothing Chats: The Future Prospects

Nothing Chats was an ambitious attempt to bridge the gap between iOS and Android users, and to offer a competitive alternative to iMessage. However, the app also raised serious privacy and security questions, and faced a swift backlash from Google Play and the tech community. The app’s removal from the Play Store has cast a shadow over its future prospects, and over Nothing’s reputation as a tech innovator.

Nothing might still be able to fix the issues and relaunch the app, but it will have to convince both Google Play and the users that it respects their privacy and security. Nothing will also have to deal with the potential legal and technical challenges from Apple, which might not be happy with the app’s use of iMessage. Nothing Chats might have gone silent for now, but it might not be the end of the story.

Summary Table